The Crusader men’s soccer program has had numerous team and individual accolades in the program’s first 29 seasons. Among those successes are:
- Three conference regular season titles
- One conference tournament championship and NCAA Tournament Play-in Match appearance
- 18 First Team All-League honorees, including one conference Player of the Year
- Four Coaches of the Year
- Three Goalkeepers of the Year
- One Newcomer of the Year
- Two Academic All-Region honorees, including an Academic All-American
